By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
Oxford HeraldOxford HeraldOxford Herald
  • Home
  • World
  • Europe
  • USA
  • Middle East
  • Asia
  • General
  • Business
  • Entertainment
  • Technology
  • Health
  • Sports
  • Newsroom
  • Opinions
  • Sitemap
Reading: Alito blasts lawyer’s word-salad blurring asylum law
Share
Notification Show More
Font ResizerAa
Oxford HeraldOxford Herald
Font ResizerAa
  • World
  • Travel
  • Science
  • Technology
Have an existing account? Sign In
Follow US
© 2022 Foxiz News Network. Ruby Design Company. All Rights Reserved.
Latest

Alito blasts lawyer’s word-salad blurring asylum law

Last updated: March 25, 2026 6:05 pm
RNN
8 months ago
Share
Alito blasts lawyer's word-salad blurring asylum law
SHARE

Justice Samuel Alito pushed back Tuesday on an attorney defending migrants seeking asylum, challenging the argument that those stopped at the border have “arrived in” the United States — a key issue in an immigration case.

The case stems from a Trump administration petition asking the Supreme Court to overturn a U.S. Court of ruling that found migrants remain eligible for asylum even if stopped at a port of entry on the Mexico side, concluding they had still “arrived” in the United States. The Supreme Court’s decision could determine whether migrants blocked at the border can seek asylum and how officials will handle future surges.

Kelsi Corkran, an attorney representing asylum seekers, argued that the phrases “arriving at” and “arriving in” a location carry the same meaning, and that the only difference between “at” and “in” is grammatical. 

Alito challenged that interpretation, repeatedly pressing whether migrants stopped at the border can be said to have “arrived in” the United States, a distinction that determines whether they qualify for asylum protection.

“So there’s been talk about knocking at the door. Do you think someone who comes to the front door and knocks at the door has arrived in the house? The person may have arrived at the house?” Alito asked, testing that logic.  

“No, but that’s past tense,” Corkran said. “Are they arriving in the house?”

Alito pressed Corkran again, asking whether someone still knocking outside could be said to have arrived inside the house.

“Yes, I think here the door is open,” Corkran said.

She said asylum seekers at the “threshold” should be treated as arriving. 

U.S. law allows migrants at the border to seek asylum by claiming fear of persecution, a process that can lead to legal status if approved. Critics argue the system is often abused, with some migrants filing weak claims and not appearing for hearings.

An amicus brief filed by the HIAS Foundation affirmed Corkran’s point, asserting that denying asylum for refugees not physically on U.S. soil creates a “a legal no-man’s land.”

“People are left in limbo in dangerous border towns, unable to access the process our laws guarantee to those who arrive at a port of entry and present themselves to U.S. officials standing on U.S. soil,” the brief stated. 

Solicitor General D. John Sauer argued in his brief that “arrive in the United States” does not include someone .

The Supreme Court’s ruling on the case may come as late as June.

Noncitizen charged with voting in Minnesota 2024 election after admitting mistake to investigators
Shakira, Madonna and BTS co-headline first-ever World Cup Final halftime show
Amazon Big Spring Sale kitchen deals: Up to 59% off Ninja, Cuisinart and more
Rural voters revolted because they wanted Republicans to help them. GOP didnt deliver
JD Vance arrives in Switzerland to join Kushner and Witkoff for new round of Iran negotiations
TAGGED:latestLegal
Share This Article
Facebook Email Print
Previous Article Irans remaining weapons: How Tehran can still disrupt the Strait of Hormuz Irans remaining weapons: How Tehran can still disrupt the Strait of Hormuz
Next Article Utah mom accused of kidnapping son's alleged bully, threatening him Utah mom accused of kidnapping son’s alleged bully, threatening him
about us

Runway News Network (RNN) is a UK-based digital media group operating multiple independent news platforms across the United Kingdom. We provide structured journalism, press syndication and AI-optimised news distribution for organisations seeking national and regional visibility.

  • Sitemap
  • Advertise

Find Us on Socials

Oxford HeraldOxford Herald
© Runway News Network. All Rights Reserved.
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Username or Email Address
Password

Lost your password?